The inspection is done, your buyer’s agent sends over a Form 35R, and suddenly the deal you thought was settled is back on the table. A list of repairs. A request for money. Sometimes both.
This is one of the most common places a Western Washington sale wobbles, and it’s happening more often right now. Buyers have more leverage than they did two years ago, and they know it. Here is how I walk my sellers through the response, step by step, so you protect your net and keep the buyer at the table.
Should a seller make repairs, give a credit, or lower the price after a home inspection?
In Washington, the buyer’s repair request comes on NWMLS Form 35R, and by default the seller has 3 days to respond; silence counts as a rejection. A closing-cost credit is usually the cleanest answer for cosmetic and mid-size items, but it must fit the buyer’s loan limits (often 3% to 6% of the price). Repairs make sense for hazards, failed systems, or items the lender or appraiser will require. A price cut lowers your REET slightly but also lowers the appraisal target.
By Lianne Hall | November 19, 2026
What Just Landed in Your Inbox
In Washington, the inspection contingency runs on NWMLS Form 35, the inspection addendum. If the period is left blank, the buyer gets 10 days to inspect. At the end of that window the buyer can approve the home, terminate and get their earnest money back, or send a Form 35R asking you to fix things, credit money, or reduce the price.
Two details sellers often don’t know:
- You may never see the full report. Since the July 2023 forms update, buyers can’t hand you any part of the inspector’s report without your consent. You’ll often see only the list of requests.
- The clock is short. On the default form you have 3 days to respond, and the buyer has 3 days to reply to your answer. If you don’t respond in time, Form 35 treats that as a rejection of the request, and the buyer can walk.
Your own addendum may have different numbers written in, so read the first page of your Form 35 before you do anything else.
Your Four Choices Under Form 35R
When the request comes in, you have four ways to answer:
- Agree to everything the buyer asked for.
- Agree to some items and decline the rest.
- Reject the whole request.
- Reject it and offer an alternative, such as a credit instead of a repair list.
The buyer then gets one reply: accept your answer, terminate, or counter with their own alternative. The form’s response periods don’t reset every round, so long back-and-forth negotiations are risky. Treat your first response as your best shot.
My rule: never reject outright unless you’re comfortable relisting. A flat no on a reasonable request in today’s market is often the end of the deal.
Why Buyers Are Asking for More Right Now
This isn’t your imagination. Redfin reported that 46.2% of U.S. home sales in the three months ending May 2026 included a seller concession, a record for that time of year. In the Seattle metro the share was 48.8%, close to half of all sales. By August, Redfin was calling it the strongest buyer’s market of 2026, with 44.7% of sales including a concession.
In Gig Harbor and Tacoma, that shows up most at the inspection stage. Buyers who waived inspections in 2021 and 2022 are now using them to renegotiate. The sellers who come out ahead are the ones who expected it and priced their home with some room for it.
The Case for a Closing-Cost Credit
For most cosmetic and mid-size items, a credit is my first recommendation. You don’t have to hire contractors during escrow, chase receipts, or worry that the buyer won’t like the work. The buyer gets cash at closing toward their own costs, and the repairs are theirs to handle afterward.
The catch is the buyer’s loan. Lenders cap how much a seller can contribute:
- Conventional (Fannie Mae): 3% of the price if the buyer puts less than 10% down, 6% with 10% to 25% down, and 9% with more than 25% down. Investment properties are capped at 2%.
- FHA: generally up to 6% of the sales price.
- VA: 4% of reasonable value for items VA counts as concessions; ordinary closing costs fall outside that cap.
A credit also can’t exceed the buyer’s actual closing costs and prepaids. If you already agreed to pay some of their costs in the original offer, there may not be room left. Have your agent confirm the numbers with the buyer’s lender before you sign anything.
When You Should Make the Repair Yourself
Some items should be fixed before closing, even when a credit would be easier:
- Anything the lender or appraiser will flag. Government-backed loans in particular can require certain condition items to be fixed before the loan funds. A credit doesn’t solve that.
- Active leaks, electrical hazards, and failed systems. These scare the next buyer if the deal falls apart, and you’ll have to disclose them on your Form 17 once you know about them.
- Septic and well problems. In Pierce and Kitsap counties these come with county requirements of their own. I covered that in detail in my guide to selling a home on septic.
If you do repairs, use licensed contractors, keep every invoice, and get the work done before the buyer’s final walkthrough. Sloppy repairs create a second negotiation you don’t want.
When a Price Cut Makes More Sense
A price reduction is the right tool when the issue is big and the buyer’s loan has no room for more credit. It also has a small tax upside here. Washington’s REET is charged on the selling price, so cutting the price lowers your excise tax. On a home in the $551,000 to $1,551,000 bracket in Gig Harbor, a $10,000 price cut saves about $178 in combined state and local REET. A $10,000 credit saves nothing, because the price stays the same.
The trade-off: a lower contract price also lowers the appraisal target and becomes the recorded sale price that shows up in comps. For most sellers that’s minor. For anyone selling in a neighborhood where they own other property, or where every sale sets the bar, it’s worth a conversation.
If you’re still deciding when to list, the 2027 REET changes matter too. I break those down in Sell Now or Wait Until Spring in Gig Harbor?
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a seller have to respond to an inspection request in Washington?
On the default NWMLS Form 35, the seller has 3 days to respond to the buyer’s Form 35R, and the buyer has 3 days to reply. Your contract can set different periods, so check page one of your addendum.
What happens if the seller doesn’t respond to the buyer’s repair request?
Form 35 treats no response as a rejection of the buyer’s request. The buyer can then terminate and recover their earnest money, or accept the home as-is.
Can a seller ask to see the full inspection report?
Since July 2023, buyers can’t share any part of the inspector’s report without the seller’s consent. You can ask for it, and the buyer can agree, but many sellers only see the list of requests.
Is a credit or a price reduction better for the seller?
A credit is usually simpler and keeps the recorded sale price higher, but it must fit the buyer’s loan limits. A price cut lowers your REET slightly and lowers the appraisal target. The right answer depends on the buyer’s loan and the size of the issue.
Do I have to disclose problems the buyer’s inspection found if the sale falls apart?
Once you know about a material defect, you should expect to disclose it to the next buyer on your Form 17. Talk to your broker or attorney about how to describe it.
Protect Your Net Before the Inspection Ever Happens
The best inspection negotiation starts before you list. A smart list price leaves room for a reasonable request, and knowing your home’s weak spots ahead of time means nothing in the buyer’s report surprises you. When a request does land, answer quickly, answer once, and choose the tool that fits the buyer’s loan, not just the size of the number.
If you’re thinking about selling in the next year, start with a clear picture of what your home could sell for and net in today’s market.
About Lianne Hall
Lianne Hall is a Gig Harbor–based REALTOR® with Paramount Real Estate Group, serving buyers and sellers across Western Washington, from Gig Harbor and the Kitsap Peninsula to Tacoma, Puyallup, Auburn, and Seattle. She specializes in luxury and waterfront homes, relocation, and helping homeowners rightsize, combining marketing, negotiation, and investment strategy to help clients sell for top dollar and win in competitive markets. Call or text 253-853-6200.
Sources: Redfin: 46% of Home Sellers Gave Concessions to Buyers in May (June 22, 2026); Inman: Has the buyer's market arrived? Redfin data says maybe (Sept. 18, 2026); Washington REALTORS: At the Intersection of the 2023 Forms Revisions and Best Practices; The Madrona Group: Home Inspection Response (Form 35 walkthrough); Rexmont: Responding to a Buyer's Inspection Response; Fannie Mae Selling Guide B3-4.1-02, Interested Party Contributions; Lower: FHA Seller Concession Limits (updated Oct. 5, 2026); Washington DOR: Real estate excise tax (graduated rates). This article is general information, not legal, tax, or lending advice. Form defaults can change and your contract may differ; confirm the details with your broker, the buyer’s lender, and your attorney or CPA.