Moving From California to Washington: The Real Math

Table of Contents

People are moving from California to Washington because of the taxes. Most of them are half right.

I grew up in Newport Beach. I know exactly what you’d be giving up, and after more than 10 years of buying, selling, and investing up here, I know exactly what you’d be getting. So here’s the real math on moving from California to Washington: the taxes that go down, the ones that go up, and what your California equity buys you up here. That last part is the game changer.

It's a Trade, Not a Discount

California is where a lot of my buyers are coming from right now. In 2024, about 43,900 people moved to Washington from California.

Here’s what most of them believe on the drive up: no income tax, cheaper houses, everything up here costs less. Easy win.

That’s not quite it. Washington is not cheaper across the board, and some things up here cost quite a bit more. Moving from California to Washington is a trade, and whether you win it depends on three things: what you earn, what you own, and how close to the water you want to live.

I’ve sat across the table from plenty of California families making this move. My latest couple came from the Bay Area because the taxes were hammering them. Another left because half their day was spent sitting in a car. Both had a reason. Both did the math first.

The Income Tax Savings Are Real

Yes, the no-income-tax part is real. California has the highest top income tax rate in the country, 13.3%. Most two-income professional households top out closer to 9.3%, plus California’s disability insurance (SDI): 1.3% on every dollar of wages, no cap.

Take a Bay Area couple earning $300,000. California takes roughly $20,000 a year in state income tax, plus almost $4,000 more in SDI. Earning $150,000 in Orange County? The number is smaller, but not by as much as you’d think. You’re still in the 9.3% bracket on part of your income, plus SDI on every dollar.

In Washington, that line on your pay stub is zero. For the Bay Area couple, that’s about $23,000 a year, every year. That’s a car payment.

Now the asterisk. Washington just passed its first income tax: 9.9%, only on income over $1 million a year, starting in 2028. If you earn under a million, it won’t touch you, but it tells you something. Washington is not a state that will never tax income. And Washington already taxes long-term capital gains on things like stocks. If you live off a brokerage account, you need a different conversation than a W-2 household.

The people winning the most on this move are two-income W-2 households bringing Bay Area salaries with them.

What Your California Equity Buys Up Here

The income tax isn’t the biggest number in this move. Not even close. The biggest number is what your California house turns into up here.

The typical home value in Newport Beach is about $3.7 million, and that’s not waterfront. That’s just a typical home. In Santa Clara, a single-family median is around $1.9 million. In Gig Harbor, our median is just under $1 million.

A Bay Area seller with $1.9 million in equity can do something up here that’s almost impossible down there: buy the home with cash, or close to it, and still have money left in the bank. No mortgage. In this market, that changes how you sleep at night.

Then there’s waterfront. Waterfront homes in Gig Harbor and Fox Island have sold for a median of about $1.4 million, with an average of more than 100 feet of shoreline. That works out to around $560 a square foot. A typical Newport Beach home, not on the water, runs around $1,500 a square foot. In Newport, $3.7 million gets you into the zip code. Up here, that same equity can put you on the water, often with a dock, and money left over.

I have a small beach house up here, and I’d never be able to afford something like it in Newport. That’s why so many California sellers aren’t just moving here. They’re staying. And that’s before the tax savings stack on top.

Gig Harbor, Tacoma, or Port Orchard?

Where Californians land depends on what they want day to day. This isn’t a ranking. It’s lifestyle.

  • Gig Harbor: waterfront, small-town feel, that Hallmark vibe, and no bridge to cross every day.
  • Tacoma: more city, more restaurants, and the shortest drive to the hospitals and I-5 for the airport.
  • Port Orchard: more land and more house for your money, if you don’t mind a ferry ride into Seattle.

All of it depends on the number you’re coming with. If you’re moving in the next 60 to 90 days, don’t guess. Tell me where you’re leaving from in California, and I’ll tell you the two or three places I’d look and what your price point gets you.

What Costs More in Washington

If I stopped here, this would sound like a commercial for Washington. So here’s what costs more.

Sales tax. It’s about 9.2% in Gig Harbor, versus about 7.5% in Newport Beach. Keep it in proportion, though: on $40,000 of taxable spending a year, that difference is about $600. The income tax savings in the example above were about $23,000. That’s the pattern up here. Some things cost more, but the big numbers move in your direction.

Gas. Washington is usually the second or third most expensive state for gas. California is still worse, so you’ll save at the pump, just not as much as you hoped.

Property tax. This one surprises Californians the most, and it goes up. Thanks to Prop 13, if you bought your California house 20 years ago, your bill is based on what you paid back then. You might own a $3 million house and pay $8,000 a year. Washington doesn’t work that way. You’re taxed on what your home is worth now. In Pierce County, plan on roughly 1% of your home’s value a year, sometimes a bit more. On a $1 million home, that’s around $10,000 a year. The trade: your bill may go up, but you’re buying a lot more home for it.

Prop 19, if you’re 55 or older. California lets you sell and carry your low property tax base to a new home up to three times, anywhere in California. Not Washington. When you leave, you walk away from that for good. That doesn’t mean don’t move. It means know the number before you decide, not after.

Insurance, Traffic, and the Commute You Don't Make

California has been in a homeowner’s insurance crisis for years. Big insurers stopped writing new policies, non-renewal letters went out, and a lot of people ended up on the California FAIR Plan, which mostly covers fire. So they buy a second policy for everything else. Two policies for one house.

I’m not going to tell you Washington is immune. It isn’t. Wildfire risk is real in parts of the state, and waterfront has its own insurance questions. But for most homes in Gig Harbor and Port Orchard, getting insured is still a phone call, not a crisis. My play: get an insurance quote during your inspection period, on every house you’re serious about. Never after.

Then there’s traffic. The typical driver in LA lost 86 hours to traffic last year. In the Seattle area, about 68. If you move up here and still commute into downtown Seattle every day, you’re trading traffic for traffic.

My Bay Area clients didn’t do that. They moved across the water. From Gig Harbor, you cross the Narrows Bridge and you’re in Tacoma in about 15 minutes, with JBLM and the Tacoma hospitals within easy reach. From Port Orchard, you take the Southworth ferry or drive to Bremerton for the boat, and you can be in downtown Seattle in as little as 25 minutes. A couple of days a week in the office, remote the rest, and it’s not bad at all. The commute you don’t make is the best commute there is.

Move for What You Can Measure

A lot of Californians tell me quietly on the first call that they’re tired of the politics. I’m not going to tell anyone how to vote. But Washington has its own politics. This is the state that just passed its first income tax. If that’s your main reason, do your homework: follow the state legislature, read the local paper, sit in on a city council meeting before you move.

Move up here for the things you can actually measure: lifestyle, commute, space, water, cost. Those are the things you’ll feel every single day.

And yes, the rain. It’s not a monsoon. It’s gray, it drizzles, and it’s a lot of days in a row of the same sky. Then the sun comes out, the mountain shows up over the water, and everyone in Gig Harbor acts like they’ve never seen it before. When I moved up from California, I learned fast that my short shorts weren’t going to cut it. The people who love it here go outside in any weather: good boots, good rain gear, farmers market anyway. The ones who struggle sit inside waiting for a sunny weekend.

Three Moves Before You Sell in California

If you’ve decided you’re coming, here’s how to do it without losing money on the way out. In this order:

Talk to two CPAs, one in each state, before you sell anything. California pays attention to when you actually leave. If you’re selling stock or a business, “sell then move” and “move then sell” can be very different tax bills. And the federal home sale exclusion is $250,000 for a single person and $500,000 for a married couple. If you’ve owned in California for a long time, your gain may be bigger than that. You won’t find that out on Zillow.

Plan the sale and the purchase together, before the sign goes up. Sell first, and you’re often renting, in limbo, and moving twice. Buy first, and you’re carrying two mortgages in two states. The people who do this well build the timeline backwards: a rent-back after closing, a contingent offer written the right way, or a bridge loan, depending on your situation.

Visit in November. Everybody falls in love with Gig Harbor in August. August is a liar. Come in November. Drive the commute on a Tuesday. Run your errands, get coffee, take a walk in the rain at 5:00. If you still love it, you’ll love it forever. Most of my California clients do.

The Washington Tax California Doesn't Have

One more tax tidbit. Washington has its own estate tax. California doesn’t. Right now, the exemption is $3 million per person.

Think about who’s moving up here. A California seller sells for $3.5 million, buys a waterfront home up here, and invests the rest. That gets to $3 million faster than people think, and you never have to sell anything for it to apply.

When you plan this move, bring an estate planning attorney into the room, not just your real estate agent. I’ve watched that conversation save my relocation clients real money, while I’m busy showing them the best house.

Bring Me Two Numbers

Before you sell your California home, pull two numbers: your Prop 13 assessed value and what you originally paid. Those two numbers drive your property tax math here and your capital gains math there. Most people find them out after they’ve signed. Find them out before.

Moving in the next 90 days? Bring those numbers to a free 15-minute call. Tell me where you’re leaving from, and I’ll tell you where I’d look and what you’ll get for your money. Still a year out? Start with my free California to Washington Move Checklist, and get to know the areas through my videos.

And if you’re seriously considering Gig Harbor, I’d love to show you around: the good, the rain, and the stuff the brochures leave out. Call or text me at 253-853-6200. I help buyers and sellers in Gig Harbor, Port Orchard, Tacoma, and all of Western Washington.

Share This: