Priced Out of Seattle? Where Seattle Workers Are Actually Moving

Table of Contents

If you’re priced out of Seattle, everybody has a list of where you should move. Ten cheaper places to live near Seattle, right? The problem is that those lists are opinions. People are telling you what they like.

I wanted to know where Seattle workers actually went. So I pulled the census data on 634,000 jobs in Seattle and where every one of those workers lives. Three towns stood out, north, west, and south, and the town with the brand-new train to Seattle isn’t one of them. One question decides which of the three is yours, and most people answer it wrong. I’ll give it to you at the end.

Stop Reading the Lists. Read the Census.

I sell homes on both sides of the Narrows, and I invest here. I went through this data line by line, and the first surprise was this: only about one in three people who work in Seattle actually live in Seattle. And that share is shrinking.

Outside King County, here’s where Seattle workers live:

  • North, Snohomish County: about 80,000
  • South, Pierce County: about 46,000
  • West across the water, Kitsap County: about 17,000

Now guess which one grew the most since 2019. It’s not the north. Pierce County added more Seattle workers than Snohomish did, with half the base. That tells you where the pressure is going. But the town-level numbers are where it gets really interesting.

The Town With the Train Isn't Where They Went

In August 2024, light rail opened in Lynnwood. About 28 minutes to Westlake, for about $3. You’d think that’s it: everybody priced out of Seattle moves to Lynnwood.

Here’s what the data says. Lynnwood added only 52 Seattle workers in five years. Everett actually went down. To be fair, the data runs through 2024 and the train hasn’t been open long, so watch Lynnwood. But here’s where the North End really went:

  • Marysville: up 28%
  • Lake Stevens: up 24%
  • The area east of Mill Creek: up about 51%

People drove right past that train. Why? Price. The King County single-family median is about $925,000. Lynnwood is around $720,000. Marysville is closer to $610,000. At today’s rates with 20% down, Marysville runs about $1,600 a month less than the King County median.

The North End Catch: No Train, and a Tax Line

There’s no train in Marysville. Light rail is supposed to reach South Everett in 2037 and downtown Everett in 2041. Until then, from Marysville you’re driving I-5 south through Everett, or you’re driving to Lynnwood and fighting for a spot in a garage with about 1,670 stalls.

Here’s the line most people miss. Lynnwood has the highest sales tax in the state, 10.7%, plus Sound Transit car tabs. Marysville and Lake Stevens sit north of the Sound Transit taxing line.

If your job is north of downtown, in the U District, Northgate, or anywhere you can reach from the Lynnwood station, the North End works. If you’re hybrid, it really works. Five days a week into downtown from Marysville is a long drive, with a train you can see from the freeway.

Last spring, a couple renting on Capitol Hill called me and said, “We want the town with the train.” They priced Lynnwood first. It came out about $100,000 over their budget. Hold onto them. I’ll tell you where they landed.

Port Orchard: The Commute Is a Boat

Let’s go west. In 2019, about 580 people living in Port Orchard worked in Seattle. By 2024, it was 866. That’s up about 50%. Small town, big jump.

Here’s why. The Southworth fast ferry gets you to Pier 50 in downtown Seattle in about 26 minutes, for about $2. That’s faster than a lot of people who live in Seattle get downtown. And the house at the end of that ride? The typical home in Port Orchard is worth about $555,000, about $2,000 a month less than the King County median. Kitsap is outside the Sound Transit taxing district, so there’s no Sound Transit car tab.

You might be thinking Bremerton has a fast ferry too, and it’s even cheaper. Why isn’t it on my list? Because the data didn’t move there. On top of that, this fall Bremerton’s fast ferry cut its weekday trips by about a third, so there are no fast ferries from Seattle to Bremerton from roughly 8:40 in the morning to about 2:25 in the afternoon. A cheap town on a thin schedule is a hard sell.

Port Orchard's Two Catches

Catch one: the dock. The fast ferry leaves from Southworth, on the east side. Port Orchard is spread out, and if you buy on the far side, the drive to the dock can take as long as the boat ride. Time the drive to the dock, not to Port Orchard.

Catch two: the schedule. It’s a commuter schedule, mornings in and evenings out, and it shifts with the state ferry schedule. Know the last boat home before you ever need it. And when a boat breaks (trust me, they do), have a plan B: the state car ferry from the same dock to West Seattle, or the long drive home through Tacoma.

With my Capitol Hill couple, I said, “We’re taking the ferry together.” So we did, on a Tuesday morning. He didn’t say a word for 26 minutes. He just looked at the skyline.

The Twist: Gig Harbor

Here’s the number that surprised me most. On this side of the Sound, the fastest-growing town of any real size wasn’t a cheap town at all. It was Gig Harbor, my town.

Seattle workers living here went from about 400 to over 700, up about 82%. The single-family median here is around $914,000. That’s basically King County money.

So who’s moving here from Seattle? People who aren’t priced out of a house. They’re priced out of a lifestyle. They’re paying about what they’d pay in Seattle, and they’re getting more land, maybe the water, a harbor downtown you can walk to for dinner, and usually a hybrid schedule. Nobody makes this drive five days a week for fun. I live here. I chose it, and I still pull over some nights when the mountain is out over the water. But that’s not a priced-out move. That’s a lifestyle move.

Tacoma: Where the Most Seattle Workers Live

If you’re priced out, here’s number one. 12,367 people live in Tacoma and work in Seattle. That’s more than any other city outside King County, and it grew by over 1,800 in just five years. The whole South Sound is absorbing Seattle’s workforce: Lakewood is up about 23%, University Place about 26%, and South Hill by Puyallup about 25%. Tacoma is just the biggest piece.

Is it just I-5 traffic with a cheaper price tag? Partly. But the price tag is real. Tacoma’s median sale price is around $485,000, against $925,000 for King County single-family. At today’s rates with 20% down, that’s about $2,400 a month, every month. That’s not a lifestyle upgrade. That’s the difference between house poor and fine.

I had a buyer run exactly that math on a napkin at her kitchen counter, same job either way. She bought in Tacoma and stopped checking her bank balance before she bought groceries.

Getting From Tacoma to Seattle

A cheap house with a bad commute isn’t cheap. Here’s how the people who make Tacoma work actually get to Seattle:

  • Sounder train: Tacoma Dome to King Street Station in about an hour. It runs at commute times on weekdays, so if you miss the last one home, you’re driving.
  • Light rail: it now runs to Federal Way, about 20 minutes north of Tacoma, where you can park. Trains come every 8 to 15 minutes all day, so a meeting that runs late doesn’t strand you. There’s always a next train.
  • I-5: north through Federal Way and Kent, with everybody else.

So here’s the rule: in Tacoma, where you buy matters more than what you buy. Live 10 minutes from the Tacoma Dome Station or the northbound I-5 on-ramp, and Seattle works. Live 30 minutes the other direction, and it probably won’t. Tacoma isn’t one price, either. The North End runs closer to $650,000, and other parts of the city run well under the citywide number.

Price the tax line too. Tacoma is inside the Sound Transit district, so sales tax is about 10.5%, and the Sound Transit car tab runs about 1.1% of your car’s value every year. With two cars, that can be roughly $550 a year. It’s real money. If your 8 AM is south of downtown (the stadiums, SoDo, the airport, the Kent Valley), Tacoma is your cheapest way in, period. If you’re downtown and you live by the train, it can work for you too.

The Question That Picks Your Town

Here’s the question I promised: where do you have to be at 8 AM, and how many days a week?

  • If your 8 AM is north, or you’re hybrid, the North End gets you the most per dollar.
  • If you’re downtown near the water, it’s the boat: the east side of Port Orchard.
  • If you’re south of downtown, or you’ll live by the train, it’s Tacoma.

Most people answer a different question. They ask, “Where can I afford?” The right question is, “Where am I at 8 AM?”

My Capitol Hill couple? His 8 AM is on First Avenue, four days a week, and she works from home. They didn’t buy in the town with the train, and they didn’t buy in my number one. They bought on the east side of Port Orchard, 10 minutes from the dock, and their payment is about $900 a month less than the Lynnwood house. The data shows you where people went. Your 8 AM shows you where you should go.

Run My Tuesday Test Before You Write an Offer

One more thing before you write an offer in any of these towns: price the whole year, not just the mortgage. Then run my Tuesday test. Drive it from the actual street you’d live on at 7:30 AM, ideally in the rain. Ride the real train or the real ferry, both ways. If you still love it after that, that’s your town. If you don’t, you just saved yourself the most expensive Saturday drive of your life.

Priced out of Seattle doesn’t mean out of options. It means you need the right question. Work through it with my free Seattle Commuter Move Checklist, and if you want the bigger picture, read why people are leaving Seattle and where they actually land.

Moving in the next 60 to 90 days? Call or text me at 253-853-6200. Tell me where you have to be every morning, and in 15 minutes I’ll tell you which of these towns I’d look at first. I help buyers and sellers across Gig Harbor, Port Orchard, Tacoma, and Western Washington.

Share This: